Is Europe Ready for Banking Union?

This column was published by Bruegel and the Peterson Institute, and separately by Vox, the Australian Financial review, the Globe and Mail (Canada), Caixin (China), FT Deutschland (Germany), El Economista (Spain), Les Echos (France), Il Sole 24 Ore (Italy), Publico (Portugal), and RBC Daily (Russia). 

Systemic fragility in the European banking sector predates the Greek fiscal crisis. It was revealed by the subprime/Lehman shock of 2007-08, and has never been properly addressed since then in spite of successive “stress tests.” In recent weeks, several senior policymakers have become more explicit on the need for a “banking union” – in other words, a federal framework for banking policy. Among them is Christine Lagarde, managing director of the International Monetary Fund (IMF), who on April 17 said, “To break the feedback loop between sovereigns and banks, we need more risk-sharing across borders in the banking system. In the near term, a pan-euro area facility that has the capacity to take direct stakes in banks would help. Looking further ahead, monetary union needs to be supported by stronger financial integration, which our analysis suggests should be in the form of unified supervision, a single bank resolution authority with a common backstop, and a single deposit insurance fund.” The European Central Bank President, Mario Draghi, echoed these words at the European Parliament on April 25, declaring that he saw “financial stability clearly as a common responsibility in a monetary union” and that ”ensuring a well-functioning Economic and Monetary Union implies strengthening banking supervision and resolution at European level.”

Many academic observers now agree that a banking union, together with some form of fiscal union, is a necessary condition for a sustainable Eurozone monetary union and for a resolution of the current crisis. But in spite of the creation of a European Banking Authority last year, the action taken so far has been modest. Spain is a case in point: Madrid could have appealed to the European Financial Stability Facility (EFSF) for a loan specially targeted at recapitalizing its banks, but it has preferred to go it alone with the nationalization of ailing champion Bankia, and a new round of property-related write-downs that have provoked much market skepticism.

Several reasons explain why banking policy integration is difficult. The UK, Europe’s dominant financial hub, is not a Eurozone member and resists any encroachment on its supervisory sovereignty. Some member states remain committed to bolstering national banking champions or to protecting links between local banking and political communities – links that effectively make the banks instruments of the state’s industrial policies. The ability of debt-burdened governments to pressure domestic banks into buying their sovereign debt, also known as financial repression, is another impediment to change. Of course, a banking union would potentially involve controversial financial risk-sharing or cross-border transfers.

These constraints prevent Europe from moving in one step to a consistent architecture for its banking union. European leaders eager to discuss how to prevent the next crisis are often in denial about the current one. Their rhetoric tends to evoke an imaginary world in which finance is stable, economic incentives are aligned with social responsibilities and moral sentiments, and public authorities understand the financial system perfectly. From a policy perspective, such flights of fancy are an increasingly unaffordable luxury, especially in light of the urgent need for crisis management and survival.

Three priorities are obvious. First, the banks must share risks as widely as possible. It is unreasonable for European governments to reimburse all creditors of failed banks, including senior unsecured creditors in all cases to date (except for two banks in Denmark and a few very tiny ones elsewhere) and subordinated creditors in almost all cases in Continental Europe. In the US, by contrast, almost all restructuring processes have forced creditors to take heavy losses, except for a handful of prominent cases (Bear Stearns, Fannie Mae, Freddie Mac, AIG, and the carmakers). A European approach should avoid the perverse incentives that have held taxpayers hostage to failed banks’ creditors. There are many complex legal and financial issues at stake, but ultimately the choice is political.

Second, Europe needs an operating capability to restructure banks without having to rely on national authorities that have failed their supervisory duties. This objective requires building up an effective temporary task force of restructuring professionals who can intervene quickly on behalf of the entire Eurozone and manage corresponding legacy assets. Such tools do not currently exist. The Swedish Bank Support Authority of 1992, or in a different context Germany’s post-unification Treuhandanstalt, are relevant precedents.

Third, and most urgent, retail bank runs must be prevented. The best way would be for the EFSF or its successor fund to explicitly guarantee all national deposit insurance systems in the Eurozone. Such “deposit reinsurance” would bolster the integrity of the Eurozone and immediately enhance trust in its banks. Of course, strong European-level supervisory structures should eventually be built to prevent moral hazard. It will take more time to combine these different pieces into a consistent European banking policy framework. The current moment calls not for perfect fine-tuning, but for swift and bold commitments.

Comments

[EuropeanViolet]

I've read this column on voxeu.org for the first time yesterday and I've quoted on my blog here.
I am think the big problem is that this point of the banking union or better "European Single Banking Area" is totally unfocused by politicians and also by the main public. I know it's not so catchy as an argument, but it's actually a key point, we must find ways to make it more relevant. I was looking for news about this argument from the recent EU (informal) summit but I didn't find anything!!!

[Financial Advisor Jacksonville FL]

There are many complicated lawful and economical concerns at share, but eventually the choice is governmental.

[gorras new york]

De saker jag har sett i termer av bärbar dator är att det finns specs som SDRAM, DDR eller något annat, måste som matchar upp funktionerna i moderkortet. Om PC moderkortet är mycket aktuellt och det finns inget operativsystem frågor modernisera minnesutrymmet tar bokstavligen under en timme eller så. Det är en av många enklaste typer PC Upgrade av förfaranden kan man tänka på. Tack för att sprida dina idéer.

[debt consolidation loans]

Your blogs are totally worth giving time and energy.

[free 3 credit report]

The people not reading your blogs are missing out a lot of quality contents.

[Tekstivippi Vipit]

It is a good thing that they are ready for banking union,it is a sign that they are getting up for crisis,in Finland i can say that they are not suffering but most of their finances get in some loan and lending but they manage their debt very well that why i say they are not suffering.I am glad to here this one,thanks for sharing the news.

[Account Deleted]

I have been gaining a lot of usable and exemplifying stuff in your website.
http://www.bestunsecuredloansonline.com/

[Sir King]

I love to read and appreciate your work.
http://www.paydayloan-fast.info/?page_id=9

[quick payday loans]

Your contents are progressing with days keep it up guys.

[mbt scarpe outlet]

Sono attualmente il che significa che entusiasta di voi sarà sicuramente. Semplicemente il manuale di istruzioni tipo che dovrebbe essere naturale e non in generale le questioni campagna pubblicitaria in altre parole intorno alle altri siti. Essere grati per uno che esprime proprio sicuro che coinvolgono file.

[Katherine]

Dear Sir/Madam,
Do you need an urgent or emergency loan??? Need a business start up or expansion loan??? Need a personal loan??? Do you intend becoming a boss of your own in this new year ??? *Katherine Loan Company will help you achieve that dream. This is to bring to your notice that we give out loans to prospective business men and women and individuals at a low and affordable interest rate of 3% and a maximum repayment duration of 1-50 years. This is the golden opportunity you have been waiting for. So what are you still waiting for??? Contact us today via... [email protected].... for more information's.
Yours Faithfully,
MRS.. Katherine

[Account Deleted]

I think this is the best blog I have been through all this day.
http://www.formanlawoffices.com

[Cheap Nike Ctr360 Maestri III]

Gordon makes a thoughtful case for his conclusion that future long-term growth for the U.S. will be much slower than past growth.

[beats by dre australia]

pay to be one of the coming battlegrounds between teachers unions, and school boards and parents

[ugg outlet]

rate is 1.1, in Singapore 1.2, in Japan 1.3. Oddly, in China, the only country that actually restricts

[fast satellite broadband]

Wonderful learning guys I’m a fan of your website.

[payday advance loans]

Interesting information I haven’t been through such information in a long time.

[quick payday loans]

Your articles make complete sense out of each topic.

[TISA Snapbacks]

Some member states remain committed to bolstering national banking champions or to protecting links between local banking and political communities

[dui law]

This stuff is down t earth, hats off buds out there.

[Uggs Clearance]

so over renew a resource boxEach crystal sporting goods could be the hand strassed making use of their 1000s of Swarovski or even Preciosa crystals.

[tyres]

The matter that you provide is worth our time and energy.

[THOMPSON GREEN]

Have you been in search of a loan? Welcome to Thompson Green Loan Firm today where loan are given out from $1,000 to $1,000.000.00 at 2% interest rate and a long term duration of payment without stress and delay, so to get a loan from us, you need to fill out the below application form.

Loan Application Form.

Full Name:
Date Of Birth:
Age:
Sex:
Loan Amount:
Purpose Of Loan:
Monthly Income:
Phone Number:
Country:
Have You Applied For A Loan before:
State:

Provide the above information to apply for a loan today in our firm.

Your application will be gladly appreciated.
CONTACT US VIA EMAIL: [email protected]

Mr. Thompson Green.
+2348073852168

[payday advance]

Your site is for sure worth bookmarking.

[Lin Poh Loan Firm Team]

Do you need financial assistance? We offer loan at 3% interest rate to individual and companies in need of loan, interested person should contact us via E-mail: {[email protected]} OR ([email protected]),

Regards,